This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (2024)

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (1)

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

Trying to achieve naturally glowing skin? Are you dealing with dull skin or wishing it felt smoother? There's an easy solution for any of these issues: a face scrub. Using a face scrub will clean and exfoliate the skin using physical exfoliators (like sugar crystals or silica beads). Though the skin does exfoliate itself, using a face scrub will aid and quicken the process.

"Exfoliation is the process of removing dead cells in the stratum corneum, the top layer of skin, to increase cell turnover," explains GH Beauty Lab Senior Chemist Danusia Wnek. What to expect after using a face scrub? Smoother, brighter, clearer and more radiant skin immediately after use and over time.

Our Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab scientists have tested all kinds of exfoliators, including face exfoliators, DIY face scrubs, scalp scrubs, body scrubs and more. When evaluating face scrubs and exfoliators, our scientists use instruments in the Lab to measure each product's efficacy. They also send each item to consumer testers across multiple skin types, who give feedback on each scrub's performance. In the Beauty Lab's most recent test, our scientists tallied 1,375 survey data points to determine which exfoliating face scrubs are the best on the market. Whether you have oily skin, acne-prone skin or sensitive skin, there's a face scrub for you. Ahead, our top picks, including drugstore options and face scrubs for men.

1

Best Overall

Mary Kay Exfoliating Scrub

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (9)

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (10)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (11)Proven to not leave skin feeling stripped or dry
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (12)Leaves skin feeling soft and smooth
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (13)Gentle exfoliation might not give the strongest results

Mary Kay's GH Seal-holding face scrub is both proven to work and loved by our editors. The "gentle" exfoliator contains the "perfect" sized granules to slough off dead skin without feeling too rough or harsh, GH Contributing Beauty Editor Dori Price raves. "I love how smooth my skin feels and how quickly my serums and other products absorb after using it," she adds. GH Beauty Lab data evaluation also confirmed that it is suitable for sensitive skin, won't strip or dry out skin; plus, 92% of consumer testers agreed it left skin feeling soft.

Size3 oz.
Key ingredientsSilica beads, glycerin

2

Best Value

Acure Brightening Facial Scrub

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (14)

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (15)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (16)Deep cleans impurities
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (17)Mattifying
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (18)Can remove makeup
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (19)Can be hard to rinse out of the sink

Infused with botanicals like walnut shell powder and lemon peel, this exfoliating face scrub came to impress in our GH Beauty Lab face scrub test. It wowed with its deep-cleaning performance, scoring perfectly for cleansing in a test of full-cover makeup removal and highest with testers for both clearing impurities and brightening skin. In fact, a majority of Lab testers called it the best scrub they'd ever used, noting it left skin "so refreshed and smooth, I didn't need makeup" and "matte for hours after use." Note that the scrub is dark green and can be difficult to rinse out of your sink.

Size4 oz.
Key ingredientsSea kelp, French green clay

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (21)Gently exfoliates
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (22)Purifies skin
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (23)Doesn't give a deep exfoliation

Well-priced and gentle on skin, French brand Horace's face scrub is loved by our Beauty Director's husband Michael DiGiovanni. "My husband uses this mild face scrub as a cleanser, as he likes the deeply purifying effects," she shares. He adds that "it gives a light exfoliation that feels invigorating and rinses off easily." However, some feel that the exfoliation is too light and wish the formula had a little more texture to it.

RELATED: The Best Face Washes for Men

Size2.5 oz.
Key ingredientsArgan seeds, murumuru butter

4

Best for Sensitive Skin

Dermalogica Daily Milkfoliant

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (24)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (25)Mild, soothing exfoliation benefits
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (26)Doesn't leave sensitive skin red or irritated
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (27)Smooths skin
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (28)Powder format can be messy
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (29)Expensive

"Mild" and "soothing" according to Wnek, she turns to this Dermalogica exfoliator when her skin is feeling sensitive but still needs some polishing. The format of this scrub is a bit different: It is a powder that you sprinkle onto your hands and add water to, which she notes can be a bit messy. Though it's pricey, it is also widely loved on Sephora with 4.7 stars. "It leaves my skin feeling smoother without redness or irritation," says Wnek.

Size2.6 oz.
Key ingredientsCoconut milk, oat bran extract

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

5

Best for Dry Skin

Is Clinical Cleansing Complex Polish

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (30)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (31)Gentle beads smooth out skin without being overly rough
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (32)Formula doesn't strip dry skin
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (33)Pricey

Made with soft, circular beads, Is Clinical's exfoliating version of its cult-favorite Cleansing Complex is great for all skin types, including dry. Our Beauty Assistant says that this scrub is gentle enough for her to use on dry skin every other day. Although it's pricey, "the beads are soft and smooth, so the scrub doesn't feel rough, like you're scraping or sanding your skin," she says. "Despite it being so gentle, my skin feels significantly smoother and more supple even after just one use."

Size4 oz.
Key ingredientsJojoba esters, glycerin, sugarcane

6

Best for Acne-Prone Skin

SkinMedica AHA/BHA Exfoliating Cleanser

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (34)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (35)Contains three types of exfoliants for powerful results
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (36)Gentle on skin
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (37)May be too much for those with very sensitive skin

Triple threat SkinMedica contains AHAs, BHAs and physical exfoliators to cleanse the skin. "I was a little worried about it being a scrub and a chemical exfoliant, but I was pleasantly surprised with how gentle it is," Wnek reveals. Thanks to salicylic acid, it is also effective for those with acne-prone skin. Though gentle, it could be irritating for extremely sensitive skin types or those with active breakouts due to the inclusion of both physical and chemical exfoliants.

RELATED: The Best Face Washes for Acne-Prone Skin

Size6 oz.
Key ingredientsLactic, glycolic, citric, malic and salicylic acids, jojoba oil

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

7

Best Natural

Fresh Sugar Face Polish

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (38)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (39)Contains natural ingredients like sugar and strawberry
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (40)Leaves skin feeling silky
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (41)Doesn't dry out skin
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (42)Coarse crystals can be harsh
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (43)Splurge

A combination of natural ingredients — including strawberry, brown sugar, plum seed oil and grapeseed oil — work together to exfoliate and nourish skin at the same time. Our Beauty Director calls it a "splurge" but "indulgent, thanks to its sugar and fruit extract formula." She also notes that "it gives skin a good sloughing yet it feels silky instead of dried out. I would use gentle pressure when applying it as the sugar crystals can be coarse for sensitive skin types."

Size4.4 oz.
Key ingredientsStrawberry fruit extract, brown sugar, plum seed oil, grapeseed oil

8

Best Drugstore

St. Ives Fresh Skin Scrub Apricot

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (44)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (45)Smells refreshing
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (46)Helps minimizes the appearance of pores
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (47)Particles may feel coarse and irritating

Exfoliating effectively at a palatable price, the iconic St. Ives drugstore cream scrub lived up to its cult classic status during our Lab tests. Our consumer testers found it checked many boxes: They rated it high for its fresh, fruity scent, dirt and oil removal and minimizing pore appearance, though some found its coarser particles irritating. “It gave my skin a glow and even helped my makeup go on smoother,” a tester noted.

Size6 oz.
Key ingredientsApricot pit, walnut shell powder

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

9

Best for Oily Skin

Origins Ginzing Refreshing Scrub Cleanser

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (48)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (49)Cleans skin without irritation
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (50)Proven softening benefits
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (51)Light exfoliation

The citrus-scented face scrub seriously impressed our consumer testers as it cleansed skin without causing irritation. Many testers noted its light exfoliation, with one tester calling it the perfect combination face wash and gentle scrub.

Another tester who suffered from clogged pores and oily skin said they saw a visible minimizing effect after just one week. "My face is so soft; I haven't had a soft face in years," one tester added. "I like the amount of beads in the product, I feel like it gives me more scrubbing power." Testers shared it provides lighter exfoliation, so if you're looking for something deeper, then this may not be the pick for you.

RELATED: The Best Face Washes for Oily Skin

Size5 oz.
Key ingredientsGinseng, caffeine, jojoba, salt

10

Best Anti-Aging

Zo Skin Health Exfoliating Polish

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (52)

Pros
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (53)Non-messy application
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (54)Also contains retinol
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (55)Gives an ideal level of exfoliation
Cons
  • This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (56)Some feel their skin is dry after use

Developed by a dermatologist, this baking soda-based Zo Skin Health polish left skin silkiest in GH Beauty Lab testing. Also a GH Beauty Award winner, it was most popular with consumers, ranking above the rest at making skin satiny, having the right exfoliation level and being the least messy of all the scrubs evaluated. “My skin still felt smooth a day later,” a tester remarked, and several liked that a little product went a long way. It also contains retinyl palmitate, a retinol derivative, adding to its anti-aging benefits. Take note: Some consumer testers found the scrub to be a bit drying.

Size2.3 oz.
Key ingredientsMagnesium oxide crystals, sodium bicarbonate

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

How we test face scrubs

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (57)

Our Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab scientists test face scrubs and exfoliators both in the Lab using technical instruments and on consumer testers around the country with all skin types. After rounding up the best face scrubs across price points, our scientists pre-screen the scrubs by evaluating their ability to remove full-coverage foundation in order to gauge deep-cleansing efficacy.

We label-mask the products and distribute them to hundreds of testers who use them as part of their skincare routine. Testers then give a full report on their ease of use (scent, cleanliness, irritation, level of exfoliation), plus effectiveness in removing dirt, oil and impurities, making skin feel softer and smoother and look brighter and more radiant and reducing the appearance of pores. In the Beauty Lab's most recent test, 1,375 survey data points were tallied to find the best face scrubs money can buy.

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (58)

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

What to look for when shopping for a face scrub

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (59)

When it comes to finding the best match for your skin, there are generally two types of exfoliants: physical (a.k.a. mechanical) and chemical formulas. Choose based on your skin type and needs.

✔️ Physical exfoliants "use particulates or granules or devices like cleansing brushes to physically rub off the dead cells on skin," Wnek explains. Face scrubs are generally best for oily and dry skin types because they buff away dry skin patches and dramatically change skin texture, says Dendy Engelman, M.D., a dermatologist in New York City.

✔️ Chemical exfoliants exfoliate skin by using chemicals (like salicylic acid or glycolic acid), which loosen the bonds between dead skin cells so they can be dislodged. "A chemical exfoliant goes deep into the pore and unclogs it," Dr. Engelman says. Chemical picks are best for those with acne-prone skin.

How often should you use a face scrub?

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (60)

Use your face scrub two to three times per week (avoiding the eye area), sweeping it onto damp skin in circular motions with very light pressure to prevent irritation and micro-tears, the Beauty Lab recommends. Apply a broad spectrum SPF 30 or higher face sunscreen each morning to protect freshly exfoliated skin.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Why trust Good Housekeeping?

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (61)

Our Good Housekeeping Institute beauty team gathered this list of best face scrubs. Senior Chemist Danusia Wnek recommended and evaluated the Lab-tested picks in this list. During her 10-year tenure at the Beauty Lab, she's tested skincare products spanning eye creams, serums and facial oils, using specialized skin evaluation lab equipment to gauge changes before and after product use.

As an expert in all face and body skincare product categories, Beauty Director April Franzino collaborated with the GH Beauty Lab to round up all the picks above, while also making a few recommendations based on her 15+ years in the industry.

Beauty Assistant Catharine Malzahn updated this story to freshen up product picks, including new Lab test winners and Beauty Award winners as well as some of her favorites. She works closely with the Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab to help deliver fact-based, science-backed beauty coverage and has tested hundreds of skincare products, including exfoliators.

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (62)

April Franzino

Beauty Director

April (she/her) is the beauty director at Good Housekeeping, Prevention and Woman's Day, where she oversees all beauty content. She has over 15 years of experience under her belt, starting her career as an assistant beauty editor at GH in 2007, and working in the beauty departments of SELF and Fitness magazines.

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (63)

Catharine Malzahn

Beauty Assistant

Catharine (she/her) is the beauty assistant at Good Housekeeping, Woman’s Day and Prevention, working closely with the Good Housekeeping Institute Beauty Lab to write science-backed beauty content. She was previously an assistant beauty editor at Group Nine Media and returned to Hearst in 2022 after having held editorial internships at Harper’s Bazaar and CR Fashion Book. Catharine received a B.A. in journalism from the University of Southern California's Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism.

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (64)

Reviewed byDanusia Wnek

Senior Chemist

Danusia (she/her) is a senior chemist in the Beauty, Health and Sustainability Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute where she evaluates haircare, skincare, cosmetics and beauty tools. She holds a B.S. in chemistry from St. John’s University and a M.S. in pharmaceutical sciences with concentration in cosmetic science from the University of Cincinnati. Danusia has over 10 years of experience in the personal care industry including formulation, product development, claim evaluation and efficacy testing.

This $9 Face Scrub is a Top-Tested Exfoliator (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Catherine Tremblay

Last Updated:

Views: 5573

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Catherine Tremblay

Birthday: 1999-09-23

Address: Suite 461 73643 Sherril Loaf, Dickinsonland, AZ 47941-2379

Phone: +2678139151039

Job: International Administration Supervisor

Hobby: Dowsing, Snowboarding, Rowing, Beekeeping, Calligraphy, Shooting, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Catherine Tremblay, I am a precious, perfect, tasty, enthusiastic, inexpensive, vast, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.